Thursday, December 30, 2021

Steppe ancestry entered modern Indian Populations post 900 BCE

Steppe movement into Indian subcontinent - 1650BCE and 900BCE



In this post, I analyze the date of steppe admixture with local ancestry in Swat Valley Iron age samples (avg 910 BCE) and RoopkundA (avg 850 CE) samples from Uttarakhand, India. These are the only 2 sets of good quality ancient DNA samples from the Indian subcontinent, and therefore extremely important to study the genetic changes in the subcontinent. 

 In one of my earlier posts, I analyzed all 23 RoopkundA samples and show that in that set of 13 male samples, the steppe component is not correlated with Y-HG R1a1a, instead, it is correlated with Y-hg J2. 

Saturday, December 25, 2021

Sneak Peek: No steppe ancestry in Kashmir in 1300 BCE sample?

Since the 2019 Narasimhan et al paper on Swat Valley, Pakistan samples was published, one of the key questions which remained was — When did the steppe ancestry seen in modern Indians and Pakistanis enter mainland India? 

Location and details of burzahom site
Burzahom Site: Location and few pictures of the site.

Sure, the Swat valley samples from 1200–800 BCE show steppe ancestry, but when did it enter what is now modern Pakistan? The papers claims that this happened between 1800–1500 BCE, however ancient human samples till 1500 BCE in neighbouring Bactria Margiana Archaeological Complex (BMAC) show very little evidence of steppe people having traversed there. Crossing BMAC is a must to get from Steppe to Pakistan, so the question remained. 

We may have the answer through preliminary results obtained by one of the top Indian researchers in the field of population genetics, Dr. Niraj Rai. In a conference 3 weeks ago posted on Youtube, he let slip one of his unpublished findings — That there is no steppe autosomal ancestry to be found in north India till 1300 BCE, although he refrained from stating the site explicitly. Upon going through his talk, I think the only plausible sample he is talking about is from the site of Burzahom, near Srinagar, Kashmir. We shall see if my educated guess was correct.

 


When did the steppe ancestry reach mainland India? Or was it localized to other regions than Kashmir? Question remains open.

Monday, December 20, 2021

R1a L657 in Roopkund lake, Uttarakhand from 800CE, but no Steppe

In 2019, a paper1 was published with the analysis of the remains of 38 individuals whose bones were found in Roopkund lake, Uttarakhand at an altitude of 5000m above sea level. 

Roopkund lake bones, Uttarakhand, India
Context of Roopkund Lake. a Map showing the location of Roopkund Lake. The approximate route of the Nanda Devi Raj Jat pilgrimage relative to Roopkund Lake is shown in the inset. b Image of disarticulated skeletal elements scattered around the Roopkund Lake site. Photo by Himadri Sinha Roy. c Image of Roopkund Lake and surrounding mountains. Photo by Atish Waghwase

Tuesday, December 14, 2021

David Anthony, Michael Witzel, Asko Parpola & the Potapovka horse head burial HOAX


In 1995, a paper1 was published by David Anthony, the well known kurganist, and Prof  Nikolai Vinogradov titled 'Birth of the Chariot'. The paper mainly sought to explain the findings at the Potapovka & Sintashta-Petrovka sites in Russian steppe and relate them to Vedic rituals. Before we get to the crux of this article, I first want to deal with 2 other claims made in the same 1995 paper. First one is:

Monday, December 6, 2021

Interactive Visual Ancient DNA Database Map

 


  • Click the settings wheel to choose heat map or cluster map, or to reset map.
  • Circular arrow on top right to reset map
  • + - buttons to zoom in or out
  • In the search bar, type country, group id, y haplogroup or mtDna haplogroup to only show matching samples. can clear the sort from the bottom right.
  • Once on a sample, click info to see various info on that sample. Multiple samples from same site will be clustered together. Can view each by clicking next arrow.
  • Best viewed on PC (and firefox browser apparently).
  • I will be adding samples as I see new aDna papers. Link me papers which I have missed. Thanks.

Monday, November 29, 2021

The West/East Divide among Indo-Aryan languages

Came upon two linguistic papers which clarify the relationship of Aryan languages of India with the other old language families, namely Dravidian & Munda families.

india language family map
Language Family map of India

Saturday, November 27, 2021

A Reply to the Anthrogenica clique's criticism of my Steppe Eneolithic Post

I recently wrote a post in which my analysis showed that The same ancestors which provided iranian like ancestry to Irula tribals also provided ancestry to Steppe Eneolithic as well as South Central Asia (Sarazm aDna etc). One can read the post here.

For feedback as well as spreading the post, I posted the link to a popular DNA & population genomics forum - Anthrogenica.  Quite unexpectedly, immediately after, I was suspended from Anthrogenica with no reason or message whatsoever. I always knew it is a Kurganist bastion, but never quite expected this level of censorship to opposing ideas. I am glad though, starting this blog is now worth it. Also, credit to Davidski at Eurogenes blog for allowing me on his blog comments section even with my opposing views. 

I came to know that the Moderator who banned me is a handle named Coldmountains, a handle who I have in the past ridiculed quite a lot (in Eurogenes comment section) for not finding a single R-L657 indian y haplogroup in the steppe since 2015. Poor guy comes empty handed after each successive paper when new samples from the steppe are published. His search still goes on. Meanwhile the only L657+ sample we have so far in aDna is from Roopkund lake India 800CE.

The link to my Anthrogenica thread is here. Please register and show Anthrogenica some love in this thread and elsewhere. The moderator clique there is in an echochamber and needs some awakening.

Anyway, let move on to the criticism of my post. There is just one, and sadly i couldn't reply because I was banned. Hence this post.

Kale on 25-Nov-2021 wrote

Kotias is a pseudo-haploid sample > That means rather than having two different sets of chromosomes like a real person, it is treated as having two exactly identical sets > That means the drift going to itself it going to be crazy high > If you have an edge coming out of an artificially crazy high drift, the percentage contribution has to be artificially crazy small to avoid overfitting.

This graph is completely uninformative until structured properly.

Kale is absolutely wrong here. The pseudo-haploid* samples do not cause artificial high drift edges, rather, the artificially high drift is due to just 1 sample in the label because of which heterozygosity cannot be computed for the label. This problem is solved by using 2 samples in the label even if samples are pseudo-haploid. This is not a problem for .DG samples as these are diploid genomes and allow for heterozygous calls.

This is exactly what I have done in the graph below (later). I lumped Satsurblia & Kotias into 1 label known as CHG. I will show that my conclusion does not change.

Proof of my claim is from the programmers of Admixtools in their qpGraph readme pasted below. Should have been basic reading right?

Genotypes are expected to be pseudo-haploid -- 2 samples at least per population or drift lengths on leaves are not meaningful.  

As far as edges coming out of artificially high drifts are concerned, sister clades of Kotias also did not help Kales case. See, i spent weeks on the model trying every possibility. Them not being able to read the graph is  not my problem.

Below I will paste my new qpGraph for Steppe Eneolithic which follows these principles and should be acceptable to the Kurganists as well.

  1. Worst residual ZScore below 3.
  2. CHG label now has 2 samples and therefore allows for heterozygous calls.
  3. Each admixture node has a drift edge following it rather than an immediate admixture edge. 1 or 2 admixture edges in my graph follow an immediate admixture node because the drift edge length was 0 (hence i omitted them)
  4. Non 0 drift edges implying that the edge is a true one. (This is not a strict need. qpGraph disallows immediate admixture edge if the admixed node is labeled as a number. But qpGraph allows the admixture node to be a source to another node if the label given to it is alphanumeric. This is useful if multiple admixtures together are to be modeled.)

Please click on the graph for high res mobile view. On Desktop download image and zoom in a zoomable picture viewer.

Steppe eneolithich qpgraph



DISCUSSION

After correcting all criticisms, the need for IndiaN component in Steppe eneolithic does not go away. I again prove that the same ancestors who ultimately provided ancestry to Steppe Eneolithic in 5th mil BCE also provided ancestry to Irula tribe (and by extension most of indian groups). The minute criticisms which Kurganists come up with are immaterial now, because of course they will come up with them. So far, they have been busy denying even Iranian inflow into steppe (its a mater of purity of course!), so to accept South/ SC Asian origin is a different matter altogether.

I conclude that Steppe_En is 
60% EHG + 12% CHG + 22% IndiaN related + 6% IranN related +- std errors

As I stated in my previous post:

Where this IndiaN source lived in 6th millenium bce is unknown yet, but in the vicinity of NW south asia and SC asia will be a good guess. Could be either early Mehrgarh culture or Jeitun culture but we need ancient samples from these cultures.


*pseudo-haploid genome = randomly sampling 1 allele from a biallelic SNP (Single Nucleotide polymorphism) marker.
Diploid genome = sampling both alleles of the biallelic SNP

Heterozygosity = measure of genetic variability in a population (cannot be computed with single haploid genome)