In this post, I will start getting my thoughts about the seminal SC Asian paper organized in written form. I have had these stored in my head for 2 years. The data in the paper is absolutely fantastic, and we get the first aDna from South Asia ie Swat valley. But there are so many conclusions and data analysis choices made by the authors that left me scratching my head, so much so that this post got delayed because I just have so much to say but don't know where to begin.